Be Irish, buy Irish! Should we support Irish businesses no matter what?
Uncategorized December 3rd, 2008I have a had a debate with a colleague of late around the ideas of nationalism as applied to both consumer and enterprise markets. I am a believer in Irish companies, I think Ireland, with the right policies for investment and growth could continue to punch even further above it’s weight in international trade. The question we were debating is should we buy Irish no matter what?
I think that this doesn’t really do Irish firms any favours at all. Especially in Digital Media where we are competing in global markets, if there isn’t a solid business case for using an Irish company then I don’t think we should. Being able to physically meet and the lack of language difficulties is a solid business reason but has to be balanced by quality and costs.
I believe that especially in the current climate everyone will start to do cost benefit analysis on their service providers and if costs are higher from using Irish companies then this will make them less competitive. Will our global economy mean the end of rip-off Ireland as we look for a better deal? Should we buy Irish anyway to try and support Irish firms or should those firms rationalise and look at the international market and adjust rates and quality to compete?
I say go for the best deal no matter what, but if it’s a close run thing then buy Irish. What do you think?
December 3rd, 2008 at 7:11 pm
“The question we were debating is should we buy Irish no matter what?” – Certainly not! In a global market this attitude will only delay the inevitable.
I do not think that Irish companies must necessarily be the cheapest, but they must offer some competitive advantages. We were able to do this in the past (remember the Celtic tiger before we started obsessing about property?), and we really need to be able to do it again in the future!
December 4th, 2008 at 5:15 pm
I tend to agree as you can see. This debate was brought about by some suggestions that people were somehow “cheating” Irish retailers by doing Christmas shopping in the North.
My view on this is, give the shoppers a better deal and you’ll get their custom.
December 9th, 2008 at 4:27 am
Saying that a shopper shouldn’t cross a European border to shop is ridiculous. It is a case of ‘swings and roundabouts’ – for years Northerners have been crossing the border to fill up at RoI petrol stations because of price differential. The price difference happens to be there at the moment but it shouldn’t be considered a political act for a shopper to buy from another European state where prices are cheaper. Similarly, is it “cheating” Irish farmers for McDonald’s to use Agentinian beef in their burgers? (I don’t know if they do, it’s just an example!) We can’t have a free market just when it suits us!